Loganotron

I’ve been watching American Idol for the past couple of weeks. Tonight’s performances were all pretty good. There were some standout performances and a few that left me felling just so-so. Here are my thoughts on each of the performers:

David Archuleta – Great. Simply beautiful. It just seems he’s lacking personality.
Carly Smithson – Not great. Kinda all over the place. Could be in the bottom three this week.
Syesha Mercado – Just okay. Possibly final three.
Brooke White – Good low range. Looked like she was shaking and nervous. Kinda bland. Final three?
Kristy Lee Cook – One of her better performances. A bit whiny, but good. Would be a great country western hit.
David Cook – Started out rough in the lower notes. Ended fantastic. Randy loved it: Called it best performance of the season. David teared up.
Jason Castro – Pretty good. Not as good as “Somewhere Over the Rainbow,” but good on its own. Paula looooves him. And, whoa! Simon liked it.